Monday, November 16, 2026

Is Her Spending Plan a Fantasy?

In a recent Moneyist column by Quentin Fottrell entitled “He calls my plans a fantasy: My husband says we can’t afford a $200,000-a-year retirement. Is he being cheap?”, a soon-to-be retired wife describes her “dream retirement.” Apparently, her husband believes they can’t afford her “fantasy retirement” and she wonders whether he is right or just being cheap. She has been married to this man for almost 35 years, so she probably has a pretty good idea of how he thinks.

Certainly, this is a reasonable question for soon-to-be retired spouses to discuss, but the article implies that perhaps she is on drugs or simply living in a dream world. Mr. Fottrell dismissively accuses the wife of “World Building” (a creative and imaginative process of constructing a fictional or alternative setting).

We agree with Fottrell that the husband is clearly entitled to have a say in the couple’s spending plan, but Fottrell seems overly scornful of the wife’s desires. We also disagree with Mr. Fottrell suggestion that the couple should forecast spending based on what they are comfortable withdrawing from their accounts every year rather than reverse-engineering their retirement based on what they want to spend their money on.

Clearly this situation (and arguably any discussion around household retirement spending budgets) involves discussion of spending needs and wants and would benefit from a comparison of the present value of future essential and discretionary spending with the present value of expected income and assets (i.e., calculation of the couple’s Funded Status based on reasonable assumptions about the future). This is where the Actuarial Approach shines.

So, let’s take a look at the couple’s Funded Status based on the data provided in the article, some additional data, the wife’s “dream retirement” and the default assumptions used in the Actuarial Financial Planner. 

Data and Assumptions used in the Actuarial Financial Planner

Data from the article:

  • Both spouses are age 64
  • They have $2 million accumulated savings in various accounts
  • They both have annual Social Security benefits (presumably payable immediately) of $36,000
  • He has an annual lifetime pension benefit (presumably payable immediately as a fixed single life annuity) of $38,000
  • They own a home currently valued at $1.3 million with $150,000 left on their mortgage (we will assume annual payments of $18,500 payable for 10 years.)
  • There is some reference to the husband having received an inheritance of $500,000 recently that he refused to spend on their home, but perhaps this was a reference to a different Fottrell article. We will ignore it as a separate asset source. 

Desired Spending

  • Annual recurring essential expense spending: $110,000, including healthcare expenses and taxes which may increase when they start collecting RMDs. This item is assumed to increase with inflation each year (3% per annum) and is assumed to be 100% essential.
  • Annual fixed dollar recurring discretionary expenses of $35,000. (100% Discretionary)
  • Annual travel expenses of $45,000 per year increasing with inflation. These expenses are assumed to cease after 15 years per the wife’s desire to front load these expenses (100% discretionary)
  • Annual dining expenses of $18,000 per year increasing with inflation. These expenses are also assumed to cease after 15 years. (100% discretionary)
  • While not discussed in the article, we have assumed that the wife would require three years of long-term care expenses starting in 29 years at $283,000 dollars per annum. (50% discretionary)

Other

  • We assumed that the couple would downsize their current home in ten years and would net $800,000 net of taxes from the sale and purchase of a new smaller home. (50% non-risky)
  • No legacy
  • No assumed decrease in future Social Security benefits

Results

Based on items discussed above, the couples Actuarial Financial Planner produced the following results:

  • A present value of total assets/future income of $4,736,693
  • A present value of expected/desired spending of $4,064,316
  • A rainy-day fund of $672,376 and
  • A Funded Status of 116.54%
  • Budgeted spending for the current year of $226,500
  • Expected withdrawal from their accounts for the year of $116,500, or about 5.83% of their total accounts.

Summary

By front-loading the wife’s desired travel and dining expenses, it appears that a current spending budget for this hypothetical couple in excess of $200,000 is doable and not a “fantasy.” As discussed above, it would certainly make sense for this couple to discuss the AFP results and perhaps compromise on their spending or other financial goals. This is easily accomplished by changing input items or assumptions in the workbook. 

This exercise shows the benefits of using the AFP rather than other budget models that develop fixed annual real dollar spending budgets.